Score: 9

"Hahahahahahaha"

submission: The Real 9-11 Story

date: June 8, 2008

I'm sure I saw an earlier version of this flash...

Anyway, that was great.

"Those were the wrong windows, motherfucker"

Score: 8

"Nice enough, too short, has been done before."

submission: Artext

date: August 30, 2007

It's a nice enough flash, too short though. And it has been done before, some time ago, though not in flash. Try searching for "bb aalib".

Score: 8

"LOL! But..."

submission: Final Fantasy - BM vs WM

date: August 4, 2006

A few problems:

* Wouldn't start by itself - I had to be right-clicking and stuff to play it.
* Why didn't WM's Reflect work properly? BM should have ended up as a "real beatiful woman - with real awesome titties"
* WM oughta have won. Why? Simple: Auto-life, and Holy.

How about BM vs Bard next?

Score: 8

"Astonishingly flagrant advert"

submission: MCHawking's Greatest Hits

date: May 17, 2006

That is just about the most flagrant advert I have seen on newgrounds! I'm sure there's a rule against that...

ah well, it's good though, so like I care. However I think it's a little too long, it does get tiresome after a while. And the snippets suggest the songs as being rather samey - not sure if they are or not though, I'd have to download...uhh, I mean, buy the full album.

Score: 9

"Just one issue baby!"

submission: Blow My Whistle

date: April 15, 2006

The sound doesn't quite loop properly. A minor annoyance to an otherwise great flash.

Score: 6

"Your graphics are brilliant, but..."

submission: Squaresoft's Angels

date: April 15, 2006

It's really a little short for my liking. I appreciate that flash is hard work, but really there's not a lot too it. And of course I'd have preferred to hear FF music, even if not from X-2.

Still pretty funny though.

Score: 10

"Not for the first time I wish I could vote 6."

submission: Over The Hills

date: April 9, 2006

Exemplary. One of the few truly great flashes on Newgrounds, up there with the likes of Play, HUNT, Final Fantasy Tribute.

Score: 8

"Damn brilliant"

submission: LL-Cloud's Lament

date: April 9, 2006

Lock Legion rules, Final Fantasy rules, you've made possibly the best choice for the music, you've created a flash that has serious and humourous elements to it, what's not to like? This deserves to be in the Final Fantasy Collection as well as the LL.

Score: 5

"Yep, your scoring is still buggy"

submission: Airball

date: April 7, 2006

You need to make it so the timer starts with the first click, otherwise like SHIZAAM said, I can just leave it without clicking once.
If I actually try to play the game, I think it's a little too hard myself, but it's probably the sort of thing I'd need more practice at.
If you want to be showy, music and/or sound effects would be nice, you could add little things like animated or selectable backgrounds, an explosion effect when you hit the ground, even power-ups.

Score: 6

"Well, for <20kB I guess it's OK"

submission: Tiny High / Low - 20k

date: April 6, 2006

Really having to squint at such a tiny box is annoying. And gamewise, high/low cards...well it's OK I guess, just not a particularly good game whether it's done in 20kB or 20MB.